Holiday Comp Judging Page

xInZax

Active Member
Crafter
Dec 16, 2013
444
61
28
#1
This thread is dedicated strictly to the judges. I figured we could use a standard poll, but we can always tally the votes here as well. 

Judging Shall Consist Of:
- Originality
- Detail
- Appropriate To Winter Theme
- Aesthetic Appeal

And give each player a score from 1 through 5 for each category, 5 being outstanding, 3 being Somewhat and 1 being Not Included. Write the scores for each player below in one single post and choose your top three designs and vote below. We will take those top three designs and review the scores for each of those three to choose a winner.

<form method="post" action="http://poll.pollcode.com/24496761"><table border="0" width="286" bgcolor="EEEEEE" background="http://cdn.boardhost.com/bg/carbon.gif" cellspacing="2" cellpadding="0"><tr><td colspan="2"><font face="Comic Sans MS" size="3" color="FFFFFF"><b>Holiday Build Competition</b></font></td></tr><tr><td width="5"><input type="checkbox" name="answer" value="1" id="24496761answer1"></td><td><font face="Comic Sans MS" size="3" color="FFFFFF"><label for="24496761answer1">pixelatedwolf7 & MinnieManiac</label></font></td></tr><tr><td width="5"><input type="checkbox" name="answer" value="2" id="24496761answer2"></td><td><font face="Comic Sans MS" size="3" color="FFFFFF"><label for="24496761answer2">Crazyboy983</label></font></td></tr><tr><td width="5"><input type="checkbox" name="answer" value="3" id="24496761answer3"></td><td><font face="Comic Sans MS" size="3" color="FFFFFF"><label for="24496761answer3">_Zombie_Pigman</label></font></td></tr><tr><td width="5"><input type="checkbox" name="answer" value="4" id="24496761answer4"></td><td><font face="Comic Sans MS" size="3" color="FFFFFF"><label for="24496761answer4">CreativeNJ</label></font></td></tr><tr><td width="5"><input type="checkbox" name="answer" value="5" id="24496761answer5"></td><td><font face="Comic Sans MS" size="3" color="FFFFFF"><label for="24496761answer5">pokemon99990</label></font></td></tr><tr><td width="5"><input type="checkbox" name="answer" value="6" id="24496761answer6"></td><td><font face="Comic Sans MS" size="3" color="FFFFFF"><label for="24496761answer6">AmirAti</label></font></td></tr><tr><td width="5"><input type="checkbox" name="answer" value="7" id="24496761answer7"></td><td><font face="Comic Sans MS" size="3" color="FFFFFF"><label for="24496761answer7">Babfish</label></font></td></tr><tr><td width="5"><input type="checkbox" name="answer" value="8" id="24496761answer8"></td><td><font face="Comic Sans MS" size="3" color="FFFFFF"><label for="24496761answer8">MonochromePony</label></font></td></tr><tr><td width="5"><input type="checkbox" name="answer" value="9" id="24496761answer9"></td><td><font face="Comic Sans MS" size="3" color="FFFFFF"><label for="24496761answer9">Iimgreat123</label></font></td></tr><tr><td width="5"><input type="checkbox" name="answer" value="10" id="24496761answer10"></td><td><font face="Comic Sans MS" size="3" color="FFFFFF"><label for="24496761answer10">plusNick</label></font></td></tr><tr><td width="5"><input type="checkbox" name="answer" value="11" id="24496761answer11"></td><td><font face="Comic Sans MS" size="3" color="FFFFFF"><label for="24496761answer11">ankle_biter</label></font></td></tr><tr><td width="5"><input type="checkbox" name="answer" value="12" id="24496761answer12"></td><td><font face="Comic Sans MS" size="3" color="FFFFFF"><label for="24496761answer12">Tommytubes9</label></font></td></tr><tr><td width="5"><input type="checkbox" name="answer" value="13" id="24496761answer13"></td><td><font face="Comic Sans MS" size="3" color="FFFFFF"><label for="24496761answer13">Dezzear</label></font></td></tr><tr><td colspan=2><center><input type="submit" value=" Vote ">&nbsp;&nbsp;<input type="submit" name="view" value=" View "></center></td></tr><tr><td colspan=2 align=right><font face="Comic Sans MS" size="1" color="FFFFFF">pollcode.com <a href="http://pollcode.com/"><font face="Comic Sans MS" size="1" color="FFFFFF">free polls</font></a>&nbsp;</font></td></tr></table></form>
 

misskoa

addiction.
Staff member
Owner
misskoa
misskoa
Dec 15, 2013
3,051
850
113
#3
Shouldnt there be screenshots?'
 

Avoxsas

Active Member
Supporter
Crafter
Dec 15, 2013
789
1
38
#4
Screenshots are here: http://craftblock.me/forum/thread-229.html
 

Avoxsas

Active Member
Supporter
Crafter
Dec 15, 2013
789
1
38
#5
Pixelatedwolf7 & MinnieManiac

  • Originality: 3
    Detail: 3
    Appropriate To Winter Theme: 5
    Aesthetic Appeal: 3
    Total: 14

CrazyBoy983

  • Originality: 2
    Detail: 3
    Appropriate To Winter Theme: 4
    Aesthetic Appeal: 3
    Total: 12

_ZOMBIE_PIGMAN

  • Originality: 2
    Detail: 4
    Appropriate To Winter Theme: 3
    Aesthetic Appeal: 3
    Total: 12

CreativeNJ

  • Originality: 3
    Detail: 4
    Appropriate To Winter Theme: 5
    Aesthetic Appeal: 5
    Total: 17

Pokemon99990

  • Originality: 4
    Detail: 3
    Appropriate To Winter Theme: 3
    Aesthetic Appeal: 3
    Total: 13

AmirAti

  • Originality: 4
    Detail: 4
    Appropriate To Winter Theme: 5
    Aesthetic Appeal: 2
    Total: 15

Babfish

  • Originality: 4
    Detail: 5
    Appropriate To Winter Theme: 3
    Aesthetic Appeal: 5
    Total: 17

MonochromePony

  • Originality: 4
    Detail: 3
    Appropriate To Winter Theme: 2
    Aesthetic Appeal: 3
    Total: 12

Iimgreat123

  • Originality: 4
    Detail: 3
    Appropriate To Winter Theme: 5
    Aesthetic Appeal: 2
    Total: 14

plusNick

  • Originality: 4
    Detail: 4
    Appropriate To Winter Theme: 5
    Aesthetic Appeal: 2
    Total: 15

ankle_biter

  • Originality: 5
    Detail: 5
    Appropriate To Winter Theme: 3
    Aesthetic Appeal: 5
    Total: 18

Tommytubes9

  • Originality: 4
    Detail: 4
    Appropriate To Winter Theme: 5
    Aesthetic Appeal: 4
    Total: 17

Dezzear

  • Originality: 4
    Detail: 4
    Appropriate To Winter Theme: 4
    Aesthetic Appeal: 4
    Total :16
 

Nayxerr

mths? I'm Nayxerr now!
Crafter
Dec 16, 2013
625
3
18
21
#6
Pixelatedwolf7 & MinnieManiac

Originality: 3
Detail: 3
Appropriate To Winter Theme: 5
Aesthetic Appeal: 3

Total: 14


Crazyboy983

Originality: 2
Detail: 3
Appropriate To Winter Theme: 4
Aesthetic Appeal: 3

Total: 12


_Zombie_Pigman

Originality: 3
Detail: 4
Appropriate To Winter Theme: 1
Aesthetic Appeal: 4

Total: 12


CreativeNJ  

Originality: 3
Detail: 5
Appropriate To Winter Theme: 3
Aesthetic Appeal: 5

Total: 16


Pokemon99990

Originality: 4
Detail: 3
Appropriate To Winter Theme: 2
Aesthetic Appeal: 2

Total: 13


AmirAti

Originality: 2
Detail: 3
Appropriate To Winter Theme: 5
Aesthetic Appeal: 4

Total: 14


Babfish

Originality: 3
Detail: 4
Appropriate To Winter Theme: 4
Aesthetic Appeal: 5

Total: 16


MonochromePony

Originality: 2
Detail: 3
Appropriate To Winter Theme: 2
Aesthetic Appeal: 3

Total: 10


Iimgreat123

Originality: 3
Detail: 3
Appropriate To Winter Theme: 5
Aesthetic Appeal: 3

Total: 14


plusNick

Originality: 2
Detail: 4
Appropriate To Winter Theme: 5
Aesthetic Appeal: 5

Total: 16


ankle_biter

Originality: 4
Detail: 4
Appropriate To Winter Theme: 3
Aesthetic Appeal: 4

Total: 15


tommytubes9

Originality: 4
Detail: 5
Appropriate To Winter Theme: 4
Aesthetic Appeal: 5

Total: 18



Deazzear

Originality: 4
Detail: 3
Appropriate To Winter Theme: 4
Aesthetic Appeal: 4

Total: 15
 

Avoxsas

Active Member
Supporter
Crafter
Dec 15, 2013
789
1
38
#7
vote for your 3 in the poll at the top, mthsy :p
 

Nayxerr

mths? I'm Nayxerr now!
Crafter
Dec 16, 2013
625
3
18
21
#8
I will, I just had to fix the post XD
 

Ar7ific1al

Active Member
Supporter
Crafter
Dec 15, 2013
985
6
38
26
#9
I'm going to take this time to officially disqualify CreativeNJ. If the reward is to be Designer rank (when it's done) to the best build, CreativeNJ shall not receive it. For the reason, see the ban report.
 

Ar7ific1al

Active Member
Supporter
Crafter
Dec 15, 2013
985
6
38
26
#10
Pixelatedwolf7 & MinnieManiac
Originality: 3
Detail: 3
Appropriate To Winter Theme: 5
Aesthetic Appeal: 2
Total: 13


CrazyBoy983
Originality: 1
Detail: 2
Appropriate To Winter Theme: 3
Aesthetic Appeal: 2
Total: 8


_ZOMBIE_PIGMAN
Originality: 3
Detail: 4
Appropriate To Winter Theme: 1
Aesthetic Appeal: 4
Total: 12


Pokemon99990
Originality: 3
Detail: 2
Appropriate To Winter Theme: 2
Aesthetic Appeal: 2
Total: 9


AmirAti
Originality: 4
Detail: 2
Appropriate To Winter Theme: 5
Aesthetic Appeal: 2
Total: 13


Babfish
Originality: 4
Detail: 5
Appropriate To Winter Theme: 2
Aesthetic Appeal: 5
Total: 16


MonochromePony
Originality: 3
Detail: 1
Appropriate To Winter Theme: 2
Aesthetic Appeal: 1
Total: 7


Iimgreat123
Originality: 4
Detail: 3
Appropriate To Winter Theme: 5
Aesthetic Appeal: 2
Total: 14


plusNick
Originality: 4
Detail: 4
Appropriate To Winter Theme: 5
Aesthetic Appeal: 2
Total: 15


ankle_biter
Originality: 5
Detail: 5
Appropriate To Winter Theme: 2
Aesthetic Appeal: 5
Total: 17


Tommytubes9
Originality: 4
Detail: 5
Appropriate To Winter Theme: 5
Aesthetic Appeal: 4
Total: 18


Dezzear
Originality: 4
Detail: 4
Appropriate To Winter Theme: 4
Aesthetic Appeal: 3
Total :15
 

Uu_VALKYRE_uU

Active Member
Crafter
Dec 16, 2013
1,010
6
38
36
Michigan, USA
#11
[font=Tahoma, Verdana, Arial, sans-serif]Pixelatedwolf7 & MinnieManiac [/font]
Originality: 3
Detail: 2
Appropriate To Winter Theme: 5
Aesthetic Appeal: 4
Total: 14

[font=Tahoma, Verdana, Arial, sans-serif]CrazyBoy983[/font]
Originality: 2
Detail: 4
Appropriate To Winter Theme: 3
Aesthetic Appeal: 2
Total: 11

[font=Tahoma, Verdana, Arial, sans-serif]_ZOMBIE_PIGMAN[/font]
Originality: 3
Detail: 5
Appropriate To Winter Theme: 2
Aesthetic Appeal: 4
Total: 14

EDIT:[font=Tahoma, Verdana, Arial, sans-serif] CreativeNJ (Disqualified apparently for Ban)[/font]
Originality: 3

Detail: 5

Appropriate To Winter Theme: 4

Aesthetic Appeal: 5

Total: 17

[font=Tahoma, Verdana, Arial, sans-serif]Pokemon99990[/font]
Originality: 2
Detail: 2
Appropriate To Winter Theme: 3
Aesthetic Appeal: 2
Total: 9

[font=Tahoma, Verdana, Arial, sans-serif]AmirAti[/font]
Originality: 3
Detail: 3
Appropriate To Winter Theme: 4
Aesthetic Appeal: 3
Total: 11

[font=Tahoma, Verdana, Arial, sans-serif]Babfish[/font]
Originality: 4
Detail: 3
Appropriate To Winter Theme: 3
Aesthetic Appeal: 4
Total: 14

[font=Tahoma, Verdana, Arial, sans-serif]MonochromePony[/font]
Originality: 5
Detail: 3
Appropriate To Winter Theme: 3
Aesthetic Appeal: 1
Total: 12

[font=Tahoma, Verdana, Arial, sans-serif]Iimgreat123[/font]
Originality: 4
Detail: 3
Appropriate To Winter Theme: 5
Aesthetic Appeal: 3
Total: 15

plusNick

Originality: 3
Detail: 3
Appropriate To Winter Theme: 5
Aesthetic Appeal: 3
Total: 14

ankle_biter

Originality: 4
Detail: 4
Appropriate To Winter Theme: 1
Aesthetic Appeal: 4
Total: 13

Tommytubes9

Originality: 4
Detail: 4
Appropriate To Winter Theme: 5
Aesthetic Appeal: 3
Total: 16

[font=Tahoma, Verdana, Arial, sans-serif]Dezzear[/font]
Originality: 5 
Detail: 3
Appropriate To Winter Theme: 5
Aesthetic Appeal: 5
Total :18
 

xInZax

Active Member
Crafter
Dec 16, 2013
444
61
28
#12
Here are the tallies!

Babfish - 15.75 Average
Ankle - 15.75 Average
Tommy - 17.25

What do you guys want to do about the tie?
 

Ar7ific1al

Active Member
Supporter
Crafter
Dec 15, 2013
985
6
38
26
#13
xInZaxx said:
Here are the tallies!

Babfish - 15.75 Average
Ankle - 15.75 Average
Tommy - 17.25

What do you guys want to do about the tie?
Hmmm... If they were tied for best build, I'd say come up with a new theme and have them both build again. xD But they aren't, so... Dunno.
 

Uu_VALKYRE_uU

Active Member
Crafter
Dec 16, 2013
1,010
6
38
36
Michigan, USA
#14
If I had to choose whose I liked best between Bab's & Ankle's builds, it would be Ankle. His was larger and I really liked the detail on his. It was simple and looked nice. But Bab's looked good, too. So my vote...

1st - Tommy
2nd - Ankle
3rd - Bab

Ankle only scored lower with me, mainly because his wasn't very "Winter Themed". It was just in a wintery place. Haha But I did really like his build. Maybe more so than Tommy's build even. He just lost points because it lacked the Winter Theme. :/
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 1)